For the sake of this dialogue, let’s first put aside all the authorized, moral, and sustainability points that at present exist with generative AI. Let’s assume that we’ve a magic resolution that may resolve all of these issues as they stand.
The large drawback that I’ve with generative AI proper now could be that it isn’t ok to do senior degree work – it nonetheless makes too many errors, and it makes these errors so confidently that it’s typically troublesome to establish what these errors are except the particular person overseeing the AI’s work already has vital experience within the area. Generative AI is principally an excellent assured, typically mistaken, junior developer that works very in a short time. As such, the type of roles our magically authorized/moral/sustainable generative AI would supplant are our junior roles.
The principle challenge I see is one among long run sustainability. We will have our present senior devs oversee generative AI functioning as junior devs and produce quite a lot of work. Nonetheless, we’re not getting any youthful – the senior devs are older and can method retirement ultimately. If there are not any extra juniors to turn out to be seniors, who will oversee the AI as soon as we go away? We’d have to see the AI get to the purpose the place it may begin recognizing its personal errors, right them, and have a a lot increased success fee with out hallucinations earlier than that would occur. This is able to completely need to occur earlier than sufficient of the consultants within the area have retired in order that we are able to validate the AI’s skill to do the work wanted. This is applicable to each area that AI threatens to supplant.
There was a studio named Key phrases that really tried utilizing generative AI to construct a online game as an experiment. Key phrases is a really well-known studio, having co-developed/assisted on many video games like Tremendous Mario Bros Marvel, Diablo 4, Alan Wake, COD: MW3 (2023), Starfield, Madden, Cranium and Bones, Baldur’s Gate 3, Elden Ring, and so forth. Their takeaway from making an attempt was the identical that I’ve – AI simply can’t change expertise but. Generative AI instruments completely want the experience of senior builders in an effort to attain its potential.
[Join us on Discord] and/or [Support us on Patreon]
Received a burning query you need answered?
